Complete Lullaby by returning the Toy
To complete Lullaby in Valor Mortis, collect the Weathered Key behind the crib house, recover the Toy from the locked house across the river, and place it in the original crib. Finishing the quest awards Tomorrow’s Promise Amber and 1,500 Catalysts.
Start from the Marketplace Lantern
Start from the Marketplace Lantern in Fallen Village during Chapter 3: Rendezvous. The quest begins inside the house near the water, with flames visible in the distance. Walk up to the empty crib to trigger Lullaby automatically.
The locked door on this route opens with the Weathered Key, which you collect behind the crib house. Pick it up before backtracking toward the house across the river. If you passed Lullaby earlier, you can still start and complete it after the story.
Find the Weathered Key and bring back the Toy
- Enter the house reached by heading from the Marketplace Lantern toward the water and the distant flames. The empty crib inside is your starting landmark.
- Approach the empty crib. Getting close to it automatically starts Lullaby.
- Leave the crib house through its back door. This takes you into the yard where the Weathered Key lies near the enemies.
- Pick up the Weathered Key from the ground in the yard’s corner near the enemies. You will use it to open the separate house containing the Toy.
- Backtrack past the Marketplace Lantern into the previous area, through the carriage where you found the Blunderbuss. This brings you back toward the Volunteer landmark.
- Take the right-hand path after the Volunteer and follow it to the end. Look across the river for the house you need to enter.
- Jump across the river to reach the locked house. The tree and hanging body beside the hut provide another landmark for identifying it.
- Unlock the house door with the Weathered Key. You can now enter and reach the bed holding the quest item.
- Collect the Toy from the bed inside the house. This is the item to bring back to the empty crib.
- Return to the original crib house near the Marketplace Lantern. Make your way back to the crib where Lullaby began.
- Interact with the crib to place the Toy. This completes Lullaby and awards Tomorrow’s Promise Amber along with 1,500 Catalysts.
Rewards, choices and Ambersmith
Lullaby gives Tomorrow’s Promise Amber and 1,500 Catalysts, with no reward choice to make. Tomorrow’s Promise adds regeneration to flask healing over 10 seconds, with healing multipliers of ×1.1, ×1.2 and ×1.3 across ranks I–III. Equip the Amber through the level-up menu at a Lantern if that healing effect suits your setup.
Lullaby has no dedicated quest achievement. Its Amber reward is relevant to Ambersmith, the Amber collection achievement. Another copy of Tomorrow’s Promise is available during Till Death, so that quest also matters if you want to improve the Amber through duplicate pickups.
Check the crib, key and final interaction
If Lullaby has not started, walk up to the empty crib inside the house near Marketplace. Approaching that crib is the automatic quest trigger. Use the water and distant flames to find the correct house from the Lantern.
If you reach the locked house without the Weathered Key, retrace your route to the yard behind the crib house. Check the ground in the corner near the enemies. That key opens the door to the house containing the Toy.
Picking up the Toy does not finish Lullaby. Return to the original crib and interact with it to place the Toy. That final interaction completes the quest and grants its reward.